What is the best way to take regular payments?

A table summarising the differences between credit card (CPA), cash, cheque or Bacs transfer and Direct Debit.


There are a number of different ways to take regular payments. You could use standing orders, regular payments by credit card (known as a ‘continuous payment authority’), cash, cheque or Bacs transfer. Or you could use Direct Debit.

While we obviously think Direct Debit is the simplest and most efficient option, which is best for you will depend on your business. To help you decide which is the right option for you, we’ve summarised each in this short table.

Cash/cheque/Bacs CPA Standing Order Direct Debit
What is it? One-off payments by cheque or bank transfer. A pre-authorisation from customers to take any future payments from their credit card. A fixed, regular bank transfer set up and managed by the customer. A pre-authorisation from customers to take any future payments direct from their bank account.
Transaction fees ~£1.50 + 1 hour to pay in 3% + 20p Free 1%
Failure rates Variable ~5% Variable < 1%
Flexibility Low High Low High
Late payment risk High Mid Mid None
Admin required High Mid High Low
Best for Elderly customers and one-off, high value payments Consumer subscriptions, low value payments Strictly fixed payments to small businesses All consumer subscriptions, regular bills & regular B2B invoicing.
‹ View table of contents Next page ›

Latest features

How to fix the 10 biggest mistakes with your terms and conditions of sale

Before you undertake business with a customer, you should establish the T&Cs of sale. Here are the 10 biggest mistakes made and how to fix them.

The Global Recurring Payments Tracker: July 2019 edition

The Global Recurring Payments Tracker, a collaboration with PYMNTS.com, is your monthly resource for tackling the complexities and challenges of the international recurring payments space.

Strong Customer Authentication (SCA): The complete downloadable guide

The in-depth guide to Strong Customer Authentication (SCA), including what the new requirements mean for businesses with recurring revenue and key exemptions you can leverage.

View all


Reference guides

View all