');--input-focus-border-color:Highlight;--input-focus-outline:1px solid Canvas;--input-unfocused-border-color:transparent;--input-disabled-border-color:transparent;--input-hover-border-color:#000}@media (forced-colors:active){:root{--input-focus-border-color:CanvasText;--input-unfocused-border-color:ActiveText;--input-disabled-border-color:GrayText;--input-hover-border-color:Highlight}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:required,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input:required,.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select:required,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input:required,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea:required{outline:1.5px solid selectedItem}}.annotationLayer{--scale-factor:1;left:0;pointer-events:none;position:absolute;top:0;transform-origin:0 0}.annotationLayer section{box-sizing:border-box;pointer-events:auto;position:absolute;text-align:initial;transform-origin:0 0}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.pushButton>a,.annotationLayer .linkAnnotation>a{font-size:1em;height:100%;left:0;position:absolute;top:0;width:100%}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.pushButton>canvas{height:100%;width:100%}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.pushButton>a:hover,.annotationLayer .linkAnnotation>a:hover{background:#ff0;box-shadow:0 2px 10px #ff0;opacity:.2}.annotationLayer .textAnnotation img{cursor:pointer;height:100%;position:absolute;width:100%}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input,.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea{background-image:var(--annotation-unfocused-field-background);border:2px solid var(--input-unfocused-border-color);box-sizing:border-box;font:calc(9px*var(--scale-factor)) sans-serif;height:100%;margin:0;vertical-align:top;width:100%}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:required,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input:required,.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select:required,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input:required,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea:required{outline:1.5px solid red}.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select option{padding:0}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input{border-radius:50%}.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea{resize:none}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input[disabled],.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input[disabled],.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select[disabled],.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input[disabled],.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea[disabled]{background:none;border:2px solid var(--input-disabled-border-color);cursor:not-allowed}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:hover,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input:hover,.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select:hover,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input:hover,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea:hover{border:2px solid var(--input-hover-border-color)}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:hover,.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select:hover,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input:hover,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea:hover{border-radius:2px}.annotationLayer .choiceWidgetAnnotation select:focus,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input:focus,.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation textarea:focus{background:none;border:2px solid var(--input-focus-border-color);border-radius:2px;outline:var(--input-focus-outline)}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox :focus,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton :focus{background-color:transparent;background-image:none}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox :focus{border:2px solid var(--input-focus-border-color);border-radius:2px;outline:var(--input-focus-outline)}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton :focus{border:2px solid var(--input-focus-border-color);outline:var(--input-focus-outline)}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:checked:after,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:checked:before,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input:checked:before{background-color:CanvasText;content:"";display:block;position:absolute}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:checked:after,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:checked:before{height:80%;left:45%;width:1px}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:checked:before{transform:rotate(45deg)}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input:checked:after{transform:rotate(-45deg)}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input:checked:before{border-radius:50%;height:50%;left:30%;top:20%;width:50%}.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input.comb{font-family:monospace;padding-left:2px;padding-right:0}.annotationLayer .textWidgetAnnotation input.comb:focus{width:103%}.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.checkBox input,.annotationLayer .buttonWidgetAnnotation.radioButton input{-webkit-appearance:none;appearance:none}.annotationLayer .popupTriggerArea{height:100%;width:100%}.annotationLayer .popupWrapper{font-size:calc(9px*var(--scale-factor));min-width:calc(180px*var(--scale-factor));pointer-events:none;position:absolute;width:100%}.annotationLayer .popup{word-wrap:break-word;background-color:#ff9;border-radius:calc(2px*var(--scale-factor));box-shadow:0 calc(2px*var(--scale-factor)) calc(5px*var(--scale-factor)) #888;cursor:pointer;font:message-box;margin-left:calc(5px*var(--scale-factor));max-width:calc(180px*var(--scale-factor));padding:calc(6px*var(--scale-factor));pointer-events:auto;position:absolute;white-space:normal}.annotationLayer .popup>*{font-size:calc(9px*var(--scale-factor))}.annotationLayer .popup h1{display:inline-block}.annotationLayer .popupDate{display:inline-block;margin-left:calc(5px*var(--scale-factor))}.annotationLayer .popupContent{border-top:1px solid #333;margin-top:calc(2px*var(--scale-factor));padding-top:calc(2px*var(--scale-factor))}.annotationLayer .richText>*{font-size:calc(9px*var(--scale-factor));white-space:pre-wrap}.annotationLayer .caretAnnotation,.annotationLayer .circleAnnotation svg ellipse,.annotationLayer .fileAttachmentAnnotation,.annotationLayer .freeTextAnnotation,.annotationLayer .highlightAnnotation,.annotationLayer .inkAnnotation svg polyline,.annotationLayer .lineAnnotation svg line,.annotationLayer .polygonAnnotation svg polygon,.annotationLayer .polylineAnnotation svg polyline,.annotationLayer .squareAnnotation svg rect,.annotationLayer .squigglyAnnotation,.annotationLayer .stampAnnotation,.annotationLayer .strikeoutAnnotation,.annotationLayer .underlineAnnotation{cursor:pointer}.annotationLayer .annotationTextContent,.annotationLayer section svg{height:100%;position:absolute;width:100%}.annotationLayer .annotationTextContent{color:transparent;opacity:0;pointer-events:none;-webkit-user-select:none;user-select:none}.annotationLayer .annotationTextContent span{display:inline-block;width:100%}code[class*=language-],pre[class*=language-]{word-wrap:normal;background:none;color:#000;font-family:Consolas,Monaco,Andale Mono,Ubuntu Mono,monospace;font-size:1em;-webkit-hyphens:none;hyphens:none;line-height:1.5;tab-size:4;text-align:left;text-shadow:0 1px #fff;white-space:pre;word-break:normal;word-spacing:normal}code[class*=language-] ::selection,code[class*=language-]::selection,pre[class*=language-] ::selection,pre[class*=language-]::selection{background:#b3d4fc;text-shadow:none}@media print{code[class*=language-],pre[class*=language-]{text-shadow:none}}pre[class*=language-]{margin:.5em 0;overflow:auto;padding:1em}:not(pre)>code[class*=language-],pre[class*=language-]{background:#f5f2f0}:not(pre)>code[class*=language-]{border-radius:.3em;padding:.1em;white-space:normal}.token.cdata,.token.comment,.token.doctype,.token.prolog{color:#708090}.token.punctuation{color:#999}.token.namespace{opacity:.7}.token.boolean,.token.constant,.token.deleted,.token.number,.token.property,.token.symbol,.token.tag{color:#905}.token.attr-name,.token.builtin,.token.char,.token.inserted,.token.selector,.token.string{color:#690}.language-css .token.string,.style .token.string,.token.entity,.token.operator,.token.url{background:hsla(0,0%,100%,.5);color:#9a6e3a}.token.atrule,.token.attr-value,.token.keyword{color:#07a}.token.class-name,.token.function{color:#dd4a68}.token.important,.token.regex,.token.variable{color:#e90}.token.bold,.token.important{font-weight:700}.token.italic{font-style:italic}.token.entity{cursor:help}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Averta Web;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/Averta-Regular-fd1297bf462e95eea6aa118597d8ef9e.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Averta Web;font-style:italic;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/Averta-RegularItalic-a93ae4a14814b0363207932e2c55e7bb.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Averta Web;font-style:normal;font-weight:600;src:url(/content-platform/static/Averta-Semibold-3cbea55cef956724c095d3faa96ac883.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Averta Web;font-style:italic;font-weight:600;src:url(/content-platform/static/Averta-SemiboldItalic-7962116f4e3c788c3df34f71cb41f4c1.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:"PT Serif";font-style:normal;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/PT_Serif-Web-Regular-a12d02e92a52545c0e252cb52e59a199.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:"PT Serif";font-style:italic;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/PT_Serif-Web-Italic-fbc44e1e589cb892ee02348b2a8a348c.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:"PT Serif";font-style:normal;font-weight:600;src:url(/content-platform/static/PT_Serif-Web-Bold-f86a6a1831027140ee56a79917cdd50d.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:"PT Serif";font-style:italic;font-weight:600;src:url(/content-platform/static/PT_Serif-Web-BoldItalic-dc0d330f07cb434d3df2ada512eeb3b3.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Simplon Mono;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/SimplonMono-Regular-f7db758b4f03c8b9179c1d8fe0bb44f8.woff2) format("woff2"),url(/content-platform/static/SimplonMono-Regular-4873b89276459e0daae704dc30e2966d.woff) format("woff")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Haffer;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/HafferXH-Regular-5aabd3cd7105e25df233f608f2d66bc2.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Haffer;font-style:italic;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/HafferXH-RegularItalic-8cc7af3f0d75ba1b610a1b1878ea5eee.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Haffer;font-style:normal;font-weight:500;src:url(/content-platform/static/HafferXH-Medium-dae5509349255a527ba6223b40257a7c.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Haffer;font-style:normal;font-weight:600;src:url(/content-platform/static/HafferXH-SemiBold-64a01291b8f7380359bb3642c1b1e00a.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Haffer;font-style:italic;font-weight:600;src:url(/content-platform/static/HafferXH-SemiBoldItalic-869dd4deb4c6e290c1aaf1e6a8670036.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Nudge;font-style:normal;font-weight:100;src:url(/content-platform/static/VCNudge-Thin-09f2315fb254f9dc017f0e4983166415.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Nudge;font-style:normal;font-weight:300;src:url(/content-platform/static/VCNudge-Light-dc44d09f0564da3a5f46801b8bb26cd8.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Nudge;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/VCNudge-Regular-be0a147c918c6bec670c17f5204784bb.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Nudge;font-style:normal;font-weight:700;src:url(/content-platform/static/VCNudge-Bold-822d17e33e72d439ad42d99a75ae6df0.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Nudge;font-style:normal;font-weight:800;src:url(/content-platform/static/VCNudge-ExtraBold-a2d0723b460f32bc659ad1670a00ae22.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Nudge;font-style:normal;font-weight:900;src:url(/content-platform/static/VCNudge-Black-9e870be920be60c228f9a4affa885f8d.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Para;font-style:normal;font-weight:300;src:url(/content-platform/static/Para-Central-Light-b0a58901815efc51b2b07b595eca45f7.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Para;font-style:italic;font-weight:300;src:url(/content-platform/static/Para-Central-Light-Italic-48e4a958a048c612c6a0927f538018b8.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Para;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/Para-Central-Regular-03a3a49a91a9bbf991dd6263feab3975.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:Para;font-style:normal;font-weight:700;src:url(/content-platform/static/Para-Central-Bold-3107caa8a871d45bb00cb084bcc8ffc1.otf) format("opentype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:DM Mono;font-style:normal;font-weight:300;src:url(/content-platform/static/DMMono-Light-2cf6d0b2de012ff294ce86eecb4263e5.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:DM Mono;font-style:italic;font-weight:300;src:url(/content-platform/static/DMMono-LightItalic-0e20bf0432fcf702ef0306184759a593.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:DM Mono;font-style:normal;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/DMMono-Regular-15edd89a6460acfb1a86017399e47a1f.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:DM Mono;font-style:italic;font-weight:400;src:url(/content-platform/static/DMMono-Italic-6b7b77e96ef2aa8ec8fffe2e28239719.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:DM Mono;font-style:normal;font-weight:500;src:url(/content-platform/static/DMMono-Medium-50d7af0bb966bc0570a212128d7ab24d.ttf) format("truetype")}@font-face{font-display:swap;font-family:DM Mono;font-style:italic;font-weight:500;src:url(/content-platform/static/DMMono-MediumItalic-85bff8703124566bb1a660afda35365b.ttf) format("truetype")}body,html{box-sizing:border-box;margin:0;padding:0}
What is Substance Over Form in Accounting? | GoCardless Skip to content menu Open site navigation sidebar For use case
Our customers
For small business
For enterprise
Collect Payments
Protect revenue
Open Banking
Connect to GoCardless
Help and support
News and resources
Login Sign up What is Substance Over Form in Accounting?
Written by GoCardless The GoCardless content team comprises a group of subject-matter experts in multiple fields from across GoCardless.
The authors and reviewers work in the sales, marketing, legal, and finance departments. All have in-depth knowledge and experience in various aspects of payment scheme technology and the operating rules applicable to each.
The team holds expertise in the well-established payment schemes such as UK Direct Debit, the European SEPA scheme, and the US ACH scheme, as well as in schemes operating in Scandinavia, Australia, and New Zealand. See full bio Last editedJan 2021 — 2 min read
Substance over form examples Substance over form criticisms We can help Substance over form in accounting refers to a concept that transactions recorded in the financial statements and accompanying disclosures of a company must reflect their economic substance rather than their legal form.
Whoever prepares the financial statements of a company needs to use their judgement to derive the business sense from the transactions and events in order to present them in a manner that best reflects their true essence.
At certain times the ‘legal form’' of a transaction may not provide its true image. Although the legal form can be of importance, it may be disregarded in order to present more relevant knowledge to the users of financial statements, who should not be misled.
A transaction is an instance of an event that could alter the financial status of a business entity. It is usually a contract between a buyer and seller, which gives rise to an asset for one entity and/or a liability for the other entity. Selling inventory, buying raw materials, indulging in legal agreements and getting a bank loan are all examples of business transactions.
Despite accountants knowing they should not mislead readers of a company’s financial statements, substance over form in accounting is in widespread use.
If a small adventure company in Cornwall buys a fleet of vans using a lease agreement from a bank, it will pay some of the advance cost and the remaining sum for the vans over, say, a five-year period. Now despite legally owning the vans from an ‘economic point of view’, the company will not be recognised as the ‘legal owner’ until it pays the final instalment at the end of the fifth year.
A large estate agency in London is looking to expand. It signs a contract to lease a building in Aldgate for 30 years, where the economic useful life of the building is estimated to be 35 years. In this instance, the company itself will be called the ‘lessee’ and the other party leasing its building to them as the ‘lessor’. If the lease agreement states at the end of the lease period the ownership title of the building will be transferred to the lessee (estate agent), or the lease term (time period for which the building is being leased) covers a substantial span of the useful life period expected for the building (which is the case here), then the building is owned by the lessee in economic reality. This is because although the building is legally owned by the lessor, the estate agency controls the building and derives maximum benefits from it. Therefore it should be recorded as an asset in the financial statement of the company, as it will depreciate like any normal asset and remaining payments will be deemed as a decrease in liability rather than lease rental.
Other examples include one company essentially acting as an agent for another, so it should only record a sale on behalf of the second company in the amount of their commission. But they want their sales to appear larger, so record the entire amount of a sale as revenue.
A business could hide debt liabilities in related entities, so that its debt does not appear on the balance sheet.
Substance over form is a particular concern under generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) , because it is largely rules-based and creates specific hurdles that must be achieved in order to record a transaction a certain way.
International financial reporting standards (IFRS) are more principles-based, so it is even more difficult for someone to justify hiding the intent of a transaction if they are using IFRS frameworks to construct their financial statements.
We can help If you’re interested in finding out more about fixed overhead volume variance, then get in touch with the financial experts at GoCardless . Find out how GoCardless can help you with ad hoc payments or recurring payments .
Over 85,000 businesses use GoCardless to get paid on time. Learn more about how you can improve payment processing at your business today. Interested in automating the way you get paid? GoCardless can help Contact us
Seen 'GoCardless Ltd' on your bank statement? Learn more
GoCardless Ltd, Sutton Yard, 65 Goswell Road, London, EC1V 7EN, United Kingdom
GoCardless Ltd (company registration number 07495895) is authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority under the Payment Services Regulations 2017, registration number 597190, for the provision of payment services.